Highway Quality Test

HIGHWAY QUALITY TEST

(Highway Engineering • Testing • Performance Assurance)

Table of Contents

Sand Replacement Method – Field Density Test in Highway Construction

Sand Replacement Method – Field Density Test in Highway Construction

⚡ Quick Overview

  • 🛠 Purpose: Measures in-situ dry density of soil layers.
  • 📏 Standards: Complies with MoRTH and IS 2720 Part 28.
  • 🏗 Application: Subgrade, embankment, GSB, WMM, granular base.
  • ✅ Benefit: Ensures compaction, stability, and payment compliance.
  • 📊 Execution: Excavate pit, fill with calibrated sand, calculate field dry density.

1. Introduction (Site Context)

Visual inspection cannot ensure proper compaction. The Sand Replacement Method confirms the layer matches intended dry density. Applied to subgrade, embankment, GSB, WMM, and granular bituminous layers.

2. Why This Test is Required

Highways carry heavy traffic. Inadequate compaction causes rutting, settlement, cracking. This test objectively measures field density.

  • Low density → rutting, settlement, cracking
  • Uneven compaction → differential settlement
  • Over-compaction → aggregate crushing
  • Results affect layer approval and payment

3. Relevant IS / MoRTH Clauses

  • IS 2720 (Part 28) – Sand Replacement Method for granular soils
  • IS 2720 (Part 29) – Core Cutter for cohesive soils
  • IS 2720 (Part 8) – Maximum Dry Density & Optimum Moisture
  • MoRTH 301, 305, 401, 406, 410, 501 – Layer density control

4. Apparatus

Sand Replacement Method (IS 2720 Part 28)

  • Sand Pouring Cylinder: Metal cylinder with funnel and shutter.
  • Calibrating Container: Cylinder of known volume for sand calibration.
  • Metal Tray with Central Hole: Guides pit excavation.
  • Calibrated Clean Dry Sand: Passing 1 mm sieve, free from organic matter.
  • Balance: Accurate to 1 g for sand and soil.
  • Glass Plate / Plane Surface: For calibration checks.
  • Excavation Tools: Spade, scraper, chisel, rod for digging pits.
  • Moisture Containers: For determining moisture content of soil.

Core Cutter Method (IS 2720 Part 29)

Steel cylinder driven into cohesive soil; wet/dry weight used to calculate density. Not suitable for granular soils.

Engineering Significance

The Field Density Test verifies whether the compacted soil layer on site has achieved the required dry density as specified in MoRTH. Adequate compaction is essential to control settlement, shear failure, and loss of pavement support under traffic loads.

Acceptance Criteria

MoRTH specifications generally require a minimum of 97% to 100% of the Maximum Dry Density (MDD) obtained from laboratory Proctor tests, depending on layer type and project requirements. Non-compliance leads to re-compaction or layer rejection.

Common Errors During Testing

  • Incorrect calibration of sand pouring cylinder
  • Improper excavation of test pit
  • Testing at moisture content outside OMC range

5. Step-by-Step Procedure

Sand Replacement Method (IS 2720 Part 28)

Stage 1: Calibration

  • Fill sand cylinder with sand, weigh initial weight (W₁).
  • Place cylinder over glass plate; allow sand to flow; collect and weigh sand in cone section (repeat for mean).
  • Determine calibrating container volume by filling with water and weighing.
  • Pour sand from cylinder into calibrating container; weigh remaining sand to calculate sand bulk density (γsand).

Stage 2: Field Measurement

  • Clean and level test site surface.
  • Place metal tray with central hole; dig uniform pit.
  • Collect excavated soil; determine moisture content.
  • Pour sand into pit using calibrated cylinder until pit is filled; weigh sand used.
  • Calculate pit volume from sand weight and bulk density.
  • Compute field dry density using excavated soil weight and moisture content.

Core Cutter Method (IS 2720 Part 29)

  • Drive core cutter vertically.
  • Extract carefully; trim excess soil.
  • Measure wet and dry soil weight.
  • Calculate field density.

6. Common Site Mistakes

  • Testing loose/disturbed surfaces
  • Uncalibrated sand
  • Shallow/irregular pits
  • Ignoring moisture variations
  • Testing near edges only

7. Sample Calculation

  • Sand weight = 5.20 kg
  • Sand density = 1.60 g/cc
  • Wet soil weight = 9.50 kg
  • Moisture = 10%

Volume = 5200 / 1.60 = 3250 cc
Bulk density = 9500 / 3250 = 2.92 g/cc
Dry density = 2.92 / 1.10 = 2.65 g/cc

8. Interpretation of Results

  • Subgrade ≥ 97% MDD
  • GSB/WMM ≥ 98% MDD
  • Bituminous → as per design

9. Engineer’s Notes

  • Test after final rolling
  • Avoid rain/extreme heat
  • Check OMC before compaction
  • Follow MoRTH frequency
  • Record accurately

10. FAQs

How many Field Density Tests are required?

One per 500 m² per layer unless specified.

Can it be done on wet surface?

No. Excess moisture affects results.

What if density is below required?

Re-compact and retest.

Which IS code covers it?

IS 2720 (Part 28)

Conclusion

The Sand Replacement Method ensures compaction, prevents failures, and guarantees MoRTH compliance. Accurate testing ensures durable, safe pavements.

Written by: Kishor Kumar
Civil / Highway Engineer – QA/QC & Site Execution
Source: HighwayQualityTest.com

Scroll to Top